Thursday, July 13, 2006

Hezbollah Surprised By Their Own Attack

Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah revealed that he did not know of this morning's attack prior to its occurrence. According to a mid-level Hezbollah party member, the Hezbollah leadership was not expecting the attack to come right now, not expecting such a harsh Israeli response, and is currently scrambling to come to a plan.

In January, the party leadership decided that they would capture Israeli soldiers in exchange for Lebanese prisoners. They would attack at the earliest possible time, and today happened to be that day. The Hezbollah leadership was entirely caught off guard.

Hezbollah was the most powerful force in the National Dialogue, which has been going on for the past few months. Hezbollah was dominating sessions on defining Lebanon's defense policy, and the party was getting everything it wanted.

Hezbollah's leadership knew they could maintain their power over other Lebanese political factions, but knew they had a small range in which to operate because, outside of the Shia community, Hezbollah has little to no support. The Sunni community in Lebanon is becoming radicalized against, not only Hezbollah, but Shia in general. The Sunni Interior Minister recently legalized the radical Sunni Islamist group Hezb at-Tahrir.

There is no way that other Lebanese communities will now let Hezbollah act on their own.

Israeli Response

Hezbollah was surprised by Israel's response.

When they dreamed up this plan in January, they thought the Israelis would respond as usual: bomb a few Hezbollah positions on the border, and perhaps attack Palestinian militant camps. They were not expecting the attack to occur at this fragile time with the Palestinians.

Instead, the Israelis massively destroyed Lebanese infrastructure. Bridges throughout South Lebanon have been destroyed. Almost the entire South is without power.

The Sunni Surprise

Even more surprising for Hezbollah was the Sunni response to the bombing of both the old and new roads at Damour. The Sunni in Saida explained this Israeli aggression away noting that the Israelis were trying to block Palestinian militants at Naameh from going on the attack.

According to three Sunni shop owners in Beirut from Saida, they and their families are more upset with Hezbollah than they are with Israel. In fact, they understand the Israeli position.

Isolating Hezbollah from Within the Government

The Lebanese government's response and Prime Minister Saniora's statements have further polarized the Christian, Druze, and Sunni communities against Hezbollah. The government claims they had nothing to do with the attacks and refuse to accept responsibility.

Although the government has not condemned the attacks, the people are intrepreting the current statement as being against Hezbollah's attacks. Prominent Christian politicans have already spoken out against Hezbollah's actions.

Even more, Lebanese Ambassador to the United States Farid Abboud has been recalled from his position, which is a coup for the 14 March politicians. Abboud is a close ally of Syrian appointed Lebanese President Emile Lahoud, who is Hezbollah's closest Christian ally. Sanioura was previously unable to remove Lahoud from office, but because of actions he took in Washington, DC today (I don't know the specifics) he has been recalled.

Allegedly, the Israelis are intentionally not bombing north of Damour, even though they claim they are holding the Lebanese government responsible. Israeli jets have yet to fly over Beirut. We'll see what the night brings.

Also alleged, 14 March leaders and Western governments are quickly moving to capitalize on Hezbollah's shaky position, their isolation within the Lebanese government, their military incapability in confronting the Israelis, and their loss of any support now in the international community.

23 comments:

EvilConCarne said...

I hope and pray that way you say and analyze is true.

As for the removal of Farid Aboud from his position as ambassador in Washington, DC I am so thrilled! Earlier today I emailed some contacts in the embassy there to express my embarrasment in seeing him speak live on CNN.

He spoke of the actions that occured today as those of the Lebanese and did not deferentiate Hizballah from the Lebanese Army. It took me by complete surprise that he took such a position because I knew he did not represent the government majority.

I really hope he is out!

cheers,

Evil CC

oletimer said...

These are serious allegations, if true.

We must wait and see the response of the international community.

Lebanese Pride said...

I could care less about hezbollah and the other PRO syrian rats, I ONLY care about a FREE Lebanon. I also could care less about Israel but hope they wipe hezbollah off the map, since hezbollah thinks they can do what they want in Lebanon and have a state within a state and all that bull shit. I hope Israel DESTROYS DESTROT Syria. hezbollah and other pro syrian rats should get out of the country and go back to there "real" home syria where they are dogs just ALL the syrians.

GOD BLESS AN ANTI SYRIAN LEBANON!

Renée in the USA said...

Well, the news that Lebanon's US Ambassador got yanked is making the rounds of the news outlets now:
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satelli...cle%2FShowFull

Northern Israeli said...

From here (Haifa, Israel), it seems there is an unusually wide consensus for a tough attack: on HA, on Lebanon and on Syria. I think, though, that there is a bit more controversy about bombing too much of Beirut- people here watch in TV how many Lebanese are against HA and it does affect them. The problem is that the common thought is that the people and government of Lebanon are weak. It's not only about revenge of 8 soldiers killed - people want the kidnapped soldiers. And they are affraid being viewed as weak.
As you know, the people here influence everything the Israeli government does. If somebody ("Jamal", for instance) thinks people are affraid of the rockets- he's wrong. We've all had things alot worse than those lousy rockets- and I know they can kill, even me, but I also know I could have got killed in Maxim restaurant by a terrorist funded by syria, etc.
Just like you have tourism, we have, and especially on the Lebanese border (interior tourism). But unlike you, we are not as dependant on it. When there is fighting in Lebanon, people in TLV and Haifa continue their lives. It is not the same about Beirut. I know that it's not the majority's fault, but sometimes there's just no choise.
Anyway, I hope you personally won't get affected and that innocent peopl won't get killed.

greetings

Free Cedar said...

"Allegedly, the Israelis are intentionally not bombing north of Damour, even though they claim they are holding the Lebanese government responsible."

I believe that it would be thanks to the US who cautioned Israel from overreacting. Condoleezza Rice has called for restraints from all sides to resolve the incident peacefully in a statement made in Paris on Wednesday.

However the question is how long will we have US backup in this issue, calming down Israel's wrath? Let's not forget that the US has repeatedly stated that Israel has a right to defend itself. And unless the Lebanese government takes an official stand condemning the attack the US will likely (as Israel does) interpret the kidnapping as an 'act of war' by Lebanon, and not only Hezbollah. Even though the government officially stated that they had nothing to do with the attacks and refused any responsibility, they have not officially condemned the kidnappings.

On the bright side the fact that they have recalled Abboud from his position in DC is a positive point especially after his comments on CNN. Also, in her statement made in Paris Condoleezza Rice said that Siniora is determined to achieve the release of the Israeli soldiers. I hope these steps will allow things to calm down and not escalate even more.

Anonymous said...

Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah revealed that he did not know of this morning's attack prior to its occurrence.

nasrallah didn't know? come on man. takhanta.

kadmous said...

I hope Hezbollah and Nasrallah get what they deserve. Good analysis LP.

Anonymous said...

Good post LP. I was 100% against HA's action this morning, but then all those warm and fuzzy wonderful Israelis invaded our blosphere, so now I am not so sure anymore.

The IDF might not go too deep into Lebanon to avoid an Iraqi-type situation. All we would get is the Israelis bombing our infrastructure, and HA bombing northern Israel. If it stops after a while, HA will claim victory and their popularity will increase tremendously even if our touristic season is ruined.

Don't forget that most Lebanese dislike HA, but hate Israel. There is no way around that. And a few opinions to the contrary from deep Marounistan will not change a thing.

GA.

overandout said...

How can the government condemn Hizbullah's acts? Can it really afford turning against a considerable faction of the population right now? Hizb just got us in a vicious circle of support/no support and Israel who has everything to win from its strategy will just blame the government, although the latter is known to be powerless.

Gab said...

Well there goes the airport, now if you thought the average Lebanese was pissed at Hizballah, now they have thousands of foreigners pissed.

Anonymous said...

The Druze, Sunnis, and the Christians should share the blame in this situation. After the Cedar Revolution, they could have asked themselves, "What is the main obstacle to a free and prosperous Lebanon." Only the truly idiotic would have answered Israel.
Hezbollah was the 800 lb gorilla in the room. International cooperation could have been gained to assist the dismantling of the Syria/Iran proxy. There was no political will to do so. Lebanon lacks a political leader with vision and guts. And its people are suffering because of that fact. And the country is again being used as the main battleground to solve a broader Middle East conflict.
Israeli bombs are being dropped on your country. The IDF are inside your borders. And all because of a stupid and futile gesture on the part of Nasrallah on behalf of Syria and Iran. Hopefully, Damascus won't let this stand without a military response. Which is exactly what Israel is praying for.
Kazman

jodetoad said...

It sounds like the Lebanese people are in a really difficult position, and I'm sorry.

But Hezbollah has made clear they don't give a rat's behind about the will or well-being of the people of Lebanon. They put all of you at risk, not only without consulting you, but even telling you to be unified with them.

Lebanon is being used as a pawn by other regional powers, and your people will pay the price.

Fares said...

My emotional take on the events in Lebanon

sorry kind of long, read 3rd section if you want quick.
only people with hearts and brains can read, no need for hyprocrites.
Appreciate your feedback.

also a short anry message, All Lebanon will celebrate Nasrallah death and not just few idiots who celebrated earlier in south Beirut

Nasrallah Why don't you negotiate in Hell

David said...

Please forgive my ignorance of the Lebanon, but some questions that outsiders are asking is whether these actions are going to restart the Lebanese civil war or whether Syria and Israel will fight each other on Lebanese territory? Would anyone care to venture an opinion...

Anonymous said...

I don't think Israel will be able to destroy Hezbollah (that would require occupation again) but they can damage them, hopefully enough for the Lebanese people to chase Hezbollah out and finish the Cedar Revolution.

Dr Marrella said...

This discussion regarding response to Israeli savagery is making me wretch. Let me see, when Hezbollah commandos attack the occupation forces of this terrorist state, they are the problem? Who speaks for the Palestinians who are without water, food and medicine? Not the UN not the EU. This is genocide! THIS IS THE WARSAW GHETTO. The final solution for an entire nation, and nothing short.
Do you and the frightened Christians in Lebonon honestly believe you can placate this unrestrained BLITZKRIEG with removing the only legitimate resistance, however feeble, against high tech ubermensch with diplomacy? In Munich at least the Nazis had enough respect for their victims to sit down at a table before they massacred them.
The most disheartening thing I head all week was the news reports regarding Israel's Defense Forces unfortunate duty to blow the only water line to the refugee camps so they might be able to recover their young soldier from the terrorist militants. What was so sad was that this language was not from Fox News , but from Air America.

Anonymous said...

This discussion regarding response to Israeli savagery is making me wretch. Let me see, when Hezbollah commandos attack the occupation forces of this terrorist state, they are the problem? Who speaks for the Palestinians who are without water, food and medicine? Not the UN not the EU. This is genocide! THIS IS THE WARSAW GHETTO. The final solution for an entire nation, and nothing short.
Do you and the frightened Christians in Lebonon honestly believe you can placate this unrestrained BLITZKRIEG with removing the only legitimate resistance, however feeble, against high tech ubermensch with diplomacy? In Munich at least the Nazis had enough respect for their victims to sit down at a table before they massacred them.
The most disheartening thing I head all week was the news reports regarding Israel's Defense Forces unfortunate duty to blow the only water line to the refugee camps so they might be able to recover their young soldier from the terrorist militants. What was so sad was that this language was not from Fox News , but from Air America.

angst said...

dr. marrella/anon
The mere fact that you listen to Air America pretty much gives away your leftist anti-semitic stand. Rhetoric like "Hezbollah commandos attack the occupation...." convinces no one. In case you hadn't noticed, Israel is not occupying Lebanon. But, I imagine you don't want to be confused by facts.

But wait! I see your point now.... The fact that Israel is located in the Middle East makes their existence an occupation to you. And then, you have the nerve to use Nazi phrases to describe their actions. Genocide? For a "Dr." your etymology certainly is flawed. I believe the IDF bombs don't ask for Sunni, Druze or Christian ID cards before they hit their targets- and neither do Hezbollah's missiles. Go back under the rock from which you crawled. The Lebanese don't need advice from the likes of you- there's plenty of hate going around as it is. Let them do what they have to do to be free of racist bigots- like yourself.

Anonymous said...

"Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah revealed that he did not know of this morning's attack prior to its occurrence."

Does that mean that the order actually came from Iran through the Revolutionary Guards cadre that really runs Hezbollah?

Pacific blue said...

People are really suffering because of this ignorant and vicious actions by some so called resistance movements. For so long Hezbollah has been allowed to operate freely, and this has sound disaster by dragging Lebanon into war. War is really death and destruction. How can Hezbollah defend lebanon when it cannot defend itself. Please it is time for free lebanon to stop this unwanted terrorist hezbollah for the good of their people and country. Only can then killing and destruction stop.

Anonymous said...

I just don't get it. Hez snatches a couple of IDFs and expect minimal response? Duh!

The "international community" and the hand-wringing appeasement asshats in France, Russia, and (previously) Washington, etc. have put up with far toooo much of this Islamic bullshit for farrr toooo long.

I'm putting my money on Israel in this one. Sorry if you're too bone-headed to recognize the reality of the 21st century. Islam, in it's current front-page form, needs it's ass kicked.

Anonymous said...

This whole conflict is very saddening. We live in a wonderful world, what does it take to have us all live together and enjoy this world. I have to confess that I don't understand Islam very well but it is a religion and it distresses me that some Islam fundamentalists do not want to accept other views.

Life is rather short, can we not enjoy it in our chosen corner of the world and accept differences.