The Druze community in the Chouf utterly defeated Hezbollah's attack.
On the very first night of Chouf combat, the Druze community in Aley armed with hunting rifles, kalashnikovs, and a few RPGs killed approxiamately 21 Hezbollah soldiers and captured two others. In a later conflict, Iranian "observers" were captured in Aley, according to a local source.
One scholar and educator from the Druze community explains, "Every man, young and old, came out to defend Aley. We only had the weapons in our houses. Some older men had civil war era weapons, like RPGs, but there were not many of them. I had no idea my community would be so spirited in its own defense.... Druze defend Druze. We were not fighting for our own lives, but the continuation our community."
In the village Deir Qoubel, the entire male population of the village came out to defend the town with hunting rifles and anything else available. According to a local source, the townspeople killed 11 Hezbollah attackers. One member of the community sustained injuries. The townspeople had the high ground and know the terrain well. Many people in the region are experienced hunters, mostly of small birds.
I assume that the Hezbollah fighters were not wearing body armor. From what I observed in Beirut, the Hezbollah fighters did not wear body armor there, either. However, their equipment is modern and sophisticated, and their tactics are well honed.
Druze members of the Hezbollah allied Syrian Social Nationalist Party sided with their community against their political ally. One Druze SSNP member argues, "when your guard dog becomes too powerful, you need to think about putting it to sleep." This was a war for survival.
Thirteen Hezbollah vehicles invaded the Chouf from the Bekaa Valley, but were captured in Barouk and Niha. Barouk is one of Lebanon's few wildlife sanctuaries. The sanctuary is a pet project of Druze leader Walid Jumblatt and his wife Nora, who is of Shia origins. It is one of the few places in Lebanon where the Cedar of Lebanon grows; thus it is a symbolic site for both the Druze leader and Lebanon. Niha is where the Druze religious leader the Sheikh al Aql lives. It is a religious pilgrimage site, Naby Ayoub, or St. Job. Hezbollah attacked a holy place, and were rightly prevented from committing acts of violence there.
According to media reports, the Druze community dragged out World War II era 160 millimeter shells to defend themselves. Friends living in Dahieh report that they observed the Druze descending down the mountain towards Hezbollah dominated Dahieh. She claims that ordinance (but unsure of what type) hit Dahieh and set off car alarms in her area. Many local residents fled. The Druze community made sure that Hezbollah knew that the Shia community, too, is vulnerable to attack. The only way Lebanon will remain stable, and the only way for Lebanese to live in peace is if Lebanese participate in true representative democracy and do not overturn the institutions of the state and endanger the lives of other communities.
According to a source close to the Arslan family, many supporters of pro-Syrian, pro-Hezbollah Druze leader Talal Arslan are moving away from the leader. Just like the SSNP members who sided with their communities over their political allegiances, the supporters of Arslan realize that no one will protect the Druze villages if they do not protect themselves. This is no longer an issue of politics, but one of survival.
According to Tony Badran's sources, pro-Syrian Druze leader Wi'am Wahhab and his followers have fled the Chouf and are unlikely to be allowed back. They turned on their community in its time of need.
The Druze have closed ranks. They know that no one will protect their community if they don't do it themselves. Druze know that their leader, Walid Jumblatt, like his father before him, serves three roles:
1) as the most competent and able leader of his community;
2) as a Lebanese leader;
3) as a progressive leader.
His role as a national leader prevented him from publicly endorsing the Druze community's justified campaign against Hezbollah's invasion. Jumblatt did his best to provide national and international safety and legitimacy to his community, and publicly called for peace and an end to violence. He asked for Druze unity, and ordered his supporters to turn their weapons over to pro-Syrian, pro-Hezbollah leader Talal Arslan, who took this as an opportunity to aggrandize himself giving myriad interviews, and claiming that the Chouf supports the resistance and are people of the resistance. Note that Arslan only asked the Druze community to relinquish their weapons to him, but made no demands on Hezbollah, even though it was Hezbollah who attacked the Druze community, of which Arslan is a member.
Jumblatt's community, which followed his orders completely in Beirut, knew they could not let the Chouf fall, and knew the difficult political situation Lebanon currently faces.
The Sunnis cannot and will not stop Hezbollah. Sunni supporters in the Arab world never provide the amount of support Lebanon needs. The Sunni regimes, unlike the Shia Iranian regime and the Alawite Syrian regime, are never willing to make sacrifices to get what they want. Even more worrying for the Druze, will any of the regional religious powers make sacrifices for the Druze if the community is on the verge of annihilation?
The Lebanese Christian community does not have enough internal unity or external support to insure the Druze community that it will be protected. The Druze and the Christians still have festering problems left over from the civil war, as well.
As a friend noted, the feeling in the Druze community is, "all we can do now is refuse any political concessions to Hizbullah linked to the violence, arm ourselves to the teeth, and wait to see the international reaction." He continues, "There is a sense that the Hezb does not want the Druze to be part of the Lebanese equation," especially given Hezbollah Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah's anti-Jumblatt remarks immediately prior to his militant takeover of Beirut. "Every step they have taken, given all the fronts they have opened, indicate this."
Monday, May 12, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
15 comments:
Charles,
Your post highlights that in Lebanon, when push comes to shove, political affiliation and principles fall and the sect comes first. That's the way it will always be.
Even Karami said yesterday that if assaults on the Sunni sect persist, he would fight on his sect's side.
So Hizbullah knows very well that it's best bet is really on its Shia supporters and hard-core SSNP party members.
Thanks for all the information you are providing. It seems very hard to get details about the multiple, near simultaneous battles that took place. Even family members who live in the affected areas are not sure about what did or did not happen. I, for one, would love to think that Hizbullah were defeated so completely as their actions were wrong on so many levels (shelling villagers who sheltered southerners and others at their time of need, direct responsibility for the deaths of many, bringing the army to the breaking point, risking long-term religious conflict, resorting to the use of 'terror' for political gain, closing the airport/harbor, bringing the country to a virtual standstill over a government employee and a telephone network, etc).
However, I am not completely convinced about what actually took place. For example, this article from the Guardian: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/may/13/lebanon.israelandthepalestinians
states that Hizbullah took control of Niha after fierce clashes. However, your blog, naharnet and PSP website say that Hizbullah were totally defeated and that prisoners and vehicles were captured in the Chouf area. So I am wondering what your sources are for the information you provide? Do you have any video footage or pictures or something that would convince skeptics? Are there any credible, multiple eye-witness accounts with corroborating details?
And if what you say is true then the Guardian and possibly other media is totally wrong about what happened in a way that needs to be corrected. It makes a big difference if the Druze villagers were able to stop the large, intricately planned, night-time Hizbullah attack and it makes a difference if foreign media realize that the sources they are using are wrong and possibly deceiving them.
Again, thanks for the information...I don't mean to be too skeptical but I would like to understand what really happened and why there are such large discrepancies in the media reports.
"Druze know that their leader, Walid Jumblatt, like his father before him, serves three roles:
[stuff]"
I wept when I read about all the good Sir Jumblatt has accomplished. Why has this man, a towering man among midgets, not been awarded the Peace Prize and every other prize? A friend of a friend told me if he touches your arm all your warts will vanish.
Some people think that this is all propoganda and wishful thinking. That can't be true because I don't like to think.
I <3 Kittys
Charles - i too am worried that the druze will have no one to turn to if they come under attack again, and desperately hope the army keeps its end of the deal. Any shift from that will reignite the conflict and cause great distress to the druze people.
Would non-violent protection of their villages work, for example, by setting up sit-downs on main roads prior to advances, with int'l media videocameras rolling, to avert future attacks?
- A concerned sunni lebanese from beirut.
Great post....although i believe the numbers of Hizbo deaths are greater,coming from inside information...and just to add to Joumblatts peaceful stature in this conflict...There is a story circulating in Druze circles that when 4 Amal militiamen were captured,MP Ali Hassan Khalil called Joumblatt and begged him for their release as they were close and dear to him. WJ did just that.
What a load of undocumented , propagandist , civil-war fueling load of crap.
I am against any piece of shit who is carrying a weapon these days, but so-called journalists that spread rumors and fuel the fire without offering any kind of references are just as crappy
It doesn't seem your info is so sccurate
I've cited my sources on this story. They are people from the Chouf recounting what they have been through, and what their relatives have been through.
I believe these people should have a voice, given that their media outlets have been shut down.
I would not put much faith in the guardian report...it has an agenda that makes it support anything that will harm israel and the west...hence its pro HA reports.
In the aftermath, here's what has emerged:
1) Hezbollah and Amal militias entering the area were armed with heavy machine guns, rocket propelled grenades, and plenty of ammo.
2) Villagers were armed with light weapons, including hunting rifles. If machine guns were used, limited rounds were available.
3) No Druze villages fell.
I don't think anything in the original post contradicts the above outcomes.
More importantly, what the Druze were subject to this past weekend was a campaign of terror. The fact that they withstood the onslaught deserves recognition as an act of great bravery against all odds.
The DRuze need to get the americans to provide them weapons and training. They don't stand a chance aginst the professional mercenaries from Syria and Iran.
For all of you doubters, My friends and family have recounted a very similar stories but they are in Chuoeifat not Aley. I still believe them. The women saw members of Hezbollah firebombing the nearby water store.
They all had modern M16's and equipment. The Druze were fighting with pistols, knives and hunting rifles. Some teenagers were even using rocks and clubs against Hezbollah.
If the Druze get some real weapons, Assad should be very afraid.
If Nasrallah or others might think that they can annihilate the Chouf Druze or the Lebanese Druze, they will need to do the same to the Israeli Druze, because we the Israeli Druze will then fight Nasrallah fiercely and we are well trained.
Lebanese Druze might have no one to back them up, but they have us, the Israeli Druze, and if the situation changes for the worst, we will support them in every possible way.
Nasrallah will then have to fight Israel, but this time, it won't end up like last time. His neck will be demanded from his hide in Syria, a propaganda coward!
I, as an Israeli Jew supports what the Israeli Druze said. If Nasrala will continue his attack against the Druze in lebanon, try to slaughter them and the Israeli Druze will choose to fight, Israeli Jews will stand and fight with them against these Iranian attack dogs (if they attacks Israel again that is a given of course).
This time we are ready!
the druze leader sir walid joumblat is a great leader
and i thank the israeli druze for their comments and the lebanese druze will fight to the death to protect their land and walid joumblat
Hizbullah capture of mountain village seen as threat to Israel.
Hugh Macleod in Beirut
The Guardian, Tuesday May 13 2008.
Hizbullah yesterday took control of a strategic mountain-top village in Druze heartlands south-east of the capital after fierce fighting with government allies, consolidating strategic gains that analysts said would be used in confrontations with Israel.
"Hizbullah will very soon spread all over. They will not leave any strategic part of the country in the hands of their so-called enemies," said Ahmad Moussali, a professor at the American University of Beirut and an expert on Islamist groups.
Hizbullah leader Hassan Nasrallah last week branded the western-backed, Sunni-led government "Israelis dressed in suits speaking Arabic", after ministers ordered a crackdown on his group's secure telecoms system. In response, Shia Hizbullah fighters and allies overran Sunni strongholds in west Beirut, then withdrew following a government climbdown.
Despite calls for a ceasefire, Hizbullah fighters defeated militants loyal to Druze leader Waleed Jumblatt in clashes starting on Sunday night, gaining control of Niha, a village in the southern Chouf mountains, 25 miles south-east of Beirut.
Analysts said the village provides the Iranian-backed group, also an ally of Damascus, with a crucial link between its stronghold in the eastern Bekaa Valley and the coastal highway that leads to Hizbullah's bases in Beirut's southern suburbs.
"Hizbullah have shown they are not interested in unseating Jumblatt but rather opening a possible supply route between Bekaa and the southern suburbs," said Ousama Safa, director of Beirut's Lebanese Centre for Policy Studies. "They can now use the area as a second front, behind the Bekaa."
On Sunday Hizbullah fighters took over key positions in Aley, a Druze town north of the Chouf, which abuts the main Beirut-Damascus highway, giving them control of another key artery. Both Druze areas have since been turned over to the army, which has a longstanding agreement on military cooperation with Hizbullah over Israel.
Beirut's international airport remained largely closed for a sixth day yesterday, as Hizbullah supporters continued to block its main supply road, while hundreds of foreigners, fearing a descent into civil war, fled via land routes to Syria.
A ceasefire in the northern port city of Tripoli broke down yesterday as Sunni supporters of parliamentary leader Saad Hariri exchanged machine gun and grenade fire with Alawite militiamen allied to Hizbullah.
The fighting brought the death toll in six days of conflict to 81, with 250 wounded.
Arab foreign ministers said they would send mediators, headed by Qatar, to arrive in Beirut tomorrow.
Post a Comment